Make your own free website on Tripod.com

 

Name of Writer


Editorial: Slavery

Name of first reader:

Name of second reader:

Scoring

 1 = Very Weak

 2 = Weak

 3 = Okay

  4 = Good

 5 = Excellent

1. The title is written in bold, large print (circle one)..... yes..... no

First paragraph states whether writer is for or against slavery..... yes..... no

3. Second paragraph states first reason..... yes..... no

Writer gives supporting details

 1

 2

  3

 4
  5

Writer gives accurate information

 1

 2

  3

 4
  5

4. Third paragraph states second reason.... yes..... no

Writer gives supporting details

 1

 2

  3

 4
  5

Writer gives accurate information

 1

 2

  3

 4
  5

5. Fourth paragraph states third reason.... yes..... no

Writer gives supporting details

 1

 2

  3

 4
  5

Writer gives accurate information

 1

 2

  3

 4
  5

6. Fifth paragraph offers solution to slavery..... yes..... no


Writer gives supporting details

 1

 2

  3

 4
  5

Writer gives accurate information

 1

 2

  3

 4
  5

7. How's the grammar?
Complete sentences?

 1

 2

  3

 4
  5

8. How's the spelling?

 1

 2

  3

 4
  5

Comments / suggestions of first reader.....


Comments / suggestions by second reason.....